With the recent melt down in global markets, it would be prudent to look back at historical data on the US market to see where we stand. To do this I look at major tops and bottoms in the S & P 500 obtained from weekly historical data from Yahoo Finance since 1950. The first table below shows major tops and bottoms in the S and P 500 relative to the average and standard deviation:
Table 1: S&P 500 Tops/Bottoms, Average & Standard Deviation over Time
Date
|
S & P 500 Top / Bottom
|
Average
|
Standard Deviation
|
November 25, 1968
|
108.37
|
55.37
|
24.92
|
May 18, 1970
|
72.25
|
58.26
|
26.21
|
January 2, 1973
|
119.87
|
62.90
|
28.12
|
September 30, 1974
|
62.34
|
65.38
|
28.78
|
December 22, 1980
|
136.57
|
72.26
|
29.69
|
August 2, 1982
|
103.71
|
74.74
|
31.00
|
August 17, 1987
|
335.9
|
90.93
|
53.55
|
30-Nov-87
|
223.92
|
92.37
|
55.95
|
13-Jul-98
|
1186.75
|
181.77
|
203.72
|
31-Aug-98
|
973.89
|
184.22
|
208.73
|
20-Mar-00
|
1527.46
|
218.64
|
282.52
|
2-Apr-01
|
1128.43
|
242.13
|
324.34
|
14-May-01
|
1291.96
|
244.38
|
327.45
|
10-Sep-01
|
965.8
|
250.33
|
334.93
|
11-Mar-02
|
1166.16
|
258.34
|
343.62
|
30-Sep-02
|
800.58
|
266.00
|
349.94
|
8-Oct-07
|
1561.8
|
346.50
|
427.52
|
2-Mar-09
|
683.38
|
366.81
|
443.71
|
19-Apr-10
|
1217.28
|
379.11
|
448.71
|
28-Jun-10
|
1022.58
|
381.39
|
449.82
|
2-May-11
|
1340.2
|
392.94
|
457.43
|
15-Aug-11
|
1123.53
|
397.09
|
460.40
|
13-Jul-15
|
2126.64
|
474.27
|
543.97
|
As can be seen in the table above on only one major bottom in 1974, the market tested it's long term average since 1950. We have not tested the average since 1974 for well over 40 years. The other interesting observation is that the standard deviation of the market has exceeded it's average since 1998 with the market way above its average. This coincides with the involvement of the FED in the market since 1998 post the Long Term Capital debacle and suggests that the risk in the market has increased significantly. The markets average since 1950 currently stands at about 475.
The next table shows the deviation from the average at major tops and bottoms and the return from highs to lows and lows to highs. The market in its early stages till about 1987 always peaked out at about 2 standard deviations above the average. Since 1987 the market has gotten as high as 5 standard deviations above its long term average. Bottoms tend to occur within 1.5 standard deviations from the average. Every key top at above 2 standard deviations from the mean produced a decline of at least 16%. The current market is the fourth most over extended market in history.
Table 2: No of Standard Deviations from the Average at Major S&P 500 Tops/Bottoms and Subsequent Returns from Tops to Bottoms and Bottoms to Tops
Date
|
No of Standard Deviations from Average
|
% Change
|
November 25, 1968
|
2.13
|
-33%
|
May 18, 1970
|
0.53
|
66%
|
January 2, 1973
|
2.03
|
-48%
|
September 30, 1974
|
-0.11
|
119%
|
December 22, 1980
|
2.17
|
-24%
|
August 2, 1982
|
0.93
|
224%
|
August 17, 1987
|
4.57
|
-33%
|
30-Nov-87
|
2.35
|
430%
|
13-Jul-98
|
4.93
|
-18%
|
31-Aug-98
|
3.78
|
57%
|
20-Mar-00
|
4.63
|
-26%
|
2-Apr-01
|
2.73
|
14%
|
14-May-01
|
3.20
|
-25%
|
10-Sep-01
|
2.14
|
21%
|
11-Mar-02
|
2.64
|
-31%
|
30-Sep-02
|
1.53
|
95%
|
8-Oct-07
|
2.84
|
-56%
|
2-Mar-09
|
0.71
|
78%
|
19-Apr-10
|
1.87
|
-16%
|
28-Jun-10
|
1.43
|
31%
|
2-May-11
|
2.07
|
-16%
|
15-Aug-11
|
1.58
|
89%
|
13-Jul-15
|
3.04
|
?
|
Finally drilling down to tops and bottoms since 2000, the average top to bottom decline since 2000 is 28% while the average bottom to top return since 2000 is 55%.
So the question begs what does it mean for today’s market? We have already started breaking down from over extended levels. The current market average is about 474 and standard deviation is 544. Here are some scenarios below:
Table 3: S&P 500 Possible Scenarios
Market Average (MA)+ Standard Deviation (SD)
|
S & P 500 Level
|
MA
|
474
|
MA + 1 SD
|
1018
|
MA + 2 SD
|
1562
|
MA + 3 SD
|
2106
|
The bottom line is folks we are historically over extended. We could now correct to at least 2 standard deviations above the long term average which is close to the 2008 highs near 1575 or to a standard deviation (#stdev) above the long term average as was the case at the 2008 lows near 1018 or to the long term average near 474 which we haven’t revisited since 1974. Only time will tell.
The S and P 500 has fallen over 2% this year. It is time to get some fundamental and technical perspective on the market. First the fundamentals from Multpl.com. Looking at the
Shiller P/E ratio we see that the market is into overvalued territory sporting a #P/E of over 23.
Next looking at the #
dividend yield on the S and P 500 below, it is closing in on all time lows also suggestive of an overvalued market.
For a technical picture I turn to
Permabear Doomster for some long term perspective. The market appears over stretched long term with no meaning full correction since 2011. It has broken down below 1840 after making a series of lower highs between 1940 and 2135. Market internals have broken down and bearish divergences in market indicators implies downside in the upcoming months. Currently a rally has occurred from the lows near 1800 which may not hold in the future:
Support - 2080
Resistance - 2135
All in all the risk reward trade for the long term appears to be on the down side.
Market Insight
-
Is Boeing Headed For A Buffett Bailout? Activists Want CEO Removed
-
In the corporate world, history's tendency to repeat itself is
unmistakable, yet it often reappears under a new guise, particularly in the
cyclical downfal...
28 minutes ago
-
-
Trump Rules Out Vivek Ramaswamy As VP, But The Bitcoin Advocate Could Still
End Up In An Important Position
-
Former President Donald Trump has reportedly ruled out Bitcoin advocate *Vivek
Ramaswamy* as his vice-presidential candidate, instead eyeing him for a
po...
1 hour ago
-
What Is Happening In Haiti Will Come Here Too
-
The kind of rampant civil unrest that has thrown Haiti into turmoil will
happen in the United States and other wealthy western nations too. At this
poin...
4 hours ago
-
Cornerstone Wealth Management LLC Has $2.85 Million Stock Position in Visa
Inc. (NYSE:V)
-
Cornerstone Wealth Management LLC cut its holdings in shares of Visa Inc.
(NYSE:V – Free Report) by 18.6% during the fourth quarter, according to the
compa...
4 hours ago
-
Market Talk – March 18, 2024
-
ASIA: The major Asian stock markets had a green day today: NIKKEI 225
increased 1,032.80 points or 2.67% to 39,740.44 Shanghai increased 30.29
points or ...
5 hours ago
-
S&P 500 PE Ratio
-
*Current S&P 500 PE Ratio:* 27.95 +0.18 (0.63%)
4:00 PM EDT, Mon Mar 18
6 hours ago
-
Don't Mistake Canoo Stock's "Bump" for a "Rally"
-
Don't Mistake Canoo Stock's "Bump" for a "Rally"
The electric vehicle (EV) market is witnessing a volatile period, with
Canoo (GOEV) recently experiencing ...
8 hours ago
-
Monday links: the ultimate anecdote
-
IPOs
- Apple ($AAPL) and Google ($GOOGL) are exploring putting Google's AI on
the iPhone. (spyglass.org)
- A closer look at Reddit's risks. (wi...
9 hours ago
-
ICT Liquidity Runs | Michael J. Huddleston
-
As price action traders, we're looking specifically for reference points
where there is a high probability of liquidity resting in the marketplace.
Related...
10 hours ago
-
Do Magazine Covers Contain Market Signals?
-
There has been a lot of chatter about magazine covers lately; I thought I
might clarify some of the with this post, originally published in Bloomberg
o...
12 hours ago
-
Has US-China decoupling energized American manufacturing?
-
In recent decades, the US has grown increasingly dependent on imports from
China to access a vast variety of goods. The FRED graph above shows Chinese
impo...
13 hours ago
-
Daily Market Brief
-
Subscriber content. To subscribe to the Daily Market Brief please visit
Market Services on NorthmanTrader.com. The Daily Market Brief is an
in-depth market...
14 hours ago
-
Biotech Is Back: Watch This $100 Billion Trend
-
After a rough bear market, it looks like biotech stocks are charging
higher. Here's a trend that points to more bullish action in 2024.
The post Biotech ...
15 hours ago
-
Debt Rattle March 18 2024
-
Johannes Vermeer The Concert 1663 Stolen from Gardner Museum March 18 1990,
the single largest art theft in the world. Never recovered. • Trump Warns
O...
17 hours ago
-
Mike Tyson is getting back in the ring at 58 – what could go wrong? –
Stephen Hughes
-
Mike Tyson is getting back in the ring at 58 – what could go wrong? Stephen
Hughes, Anglia Ruskin University If at 58, I were to agree to a boxing
match wi...
20 hours ago
-
Chill Time
-
Weekly report covering Gold, Equities, Crude, Dollar. A look at trade
opportunities and covering the model portfolio.
The post Chill Time appeared first ...
2 days ago
-
Why Social Trust Is Cratering: The Difference Between Elites and Commoners
-
*We trust what we own / control, and the difference between elites and
commoners is the elites own / control the wealth and power that dominate
our daily l...
3 days ago
-
Striking Gold: How to Catch a Once-in-a-Decade Breakout Move
-
In trading, timing is everything. Catching that massive breakout move that
can deliver life-changing gains is the dream of every trader. And according
to...
3 days ago
-
Election Years Are Different
-
[image: presidential cycle patterns in election years]
We are now firmly into this election year, with both major parties'
candidates determined. This m...
4 days ago
-
Weekend leverage increase
-
Dukascopy Bank is lowering its margin requirements on weekends which is
applied Fridays for all clients holding JForex Trading Accounts.
Starting 15 March...
4 days ago
-
Is NVDA Stock Headed for a Correction?
-
NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA) has undeniably emerged as a powerhouse in the
world of chips, riding high on the wave of the Artificial Intelligence (AI)
frenzy....
4 days ago
-
Weekend Update - Trendline rejection (3/8/24)
-
SPX was rejected by the blue trendline Friday. The trendline had been
sucessfully tested four times and held since November, until now. SPX has
unable ...
1 week ago
-
Catastrophic Risk: Investing and Business Implications
-
In the context of valuing companies, and sharing those valuations, I do
get suggestions from readers on companies that I should value next. While I
d...
4 weeks ago
-
Hello world!
-
Welcome to WordPress. This is your first post. Edit or delete it, then
start writing!
1 month ago
-
-
Teaching Johns Hopkins A Privilege Lesson
-
by Not Sure01/12/24Johns Hopkins Hospital Chief Diversity Officer Sherita
Hill Golden sent a letter out essentially implying that all people who
don’t look...
2 months ago
-
Mungerisms: Timeless Wisdom from Charlie Munger on Life and Business
-
"Mungerisms" are succinct expressions of wisdom and insights coined by
Charlie Munger, the Vice Chairman of Berkshire Hathaway and Warren
Buffett's longtim...
3 months ago
-
If You Find Deer or Elk Antlers on the Ground, Leave Them There, Say Some
States
-
Even though elk do shed their antlers naturally, collecting them brings up
a number of ethical issues.
5 months ago
-
It’s Crunch Time for The Daily Doom and Doom Time for The Great Recession
Blog
-
The Great Recession Blog is officially done for good, and it remains to be
seen if all my writing continues on TheDailyDoom.com. If my writing on
economi...
8 months ago
-
Innovative Industrial Properties Stock a Great Way to Play Pot Sector
-
*IIPR Stock Represents a Long-Term Opportunity*
Marijuana stocks briefly attracted investors' attention following the 2022
mid-term elections, when Maryl...
1 year ago
-
2008 analogue
-
The 2008 analogue tape looks very interesting from where we stand.
Let's anchor it to the next two Fed meetings -- since that's all that
matters -- and i...
1 year ago
-
Back to trade with Bar Replay
-
It is often said that one should not be sad about the past, but sometimes
it can be nice to return to it. Who would like to buy Tesla for $1 and
experience...
1 year ago
-
After This Holiday Rally, You Better Know When To Walk Away
-
This week’s investor insight will make you think twice about the current
stock and bond rally as we head into the end of the year. We get a lot of
questi...
1 year ago
-
How Africa Can Escape Chronic Food Insecurity Amid Climate Change
-
The toll of extreme weather events on crops underscores the region’s
challenges and need for policies to save lives and protect livelihoods.
1 year ago
-
12 Bear Market Rules To Live By – Survive & Thrive In The Next Bear Market
-
12 Bear Market Rules To Live By – Survive & Thrive In The Next Bear Market
[image: Bear Market Rules Survival Guide]
I grew up in the 1970s-1980s when th...
1 year ago
-
Growth Companies – Getting What You Want
-
What do the growth companies in your field have in common? How are they
doing so well and what can you learn from them? Growth companies usually
make a pro...
1 year ago
-
-
Blog Post Title
-
What goes into a blog post? Helpful, industry-specific content that: 1)
gives readers a useful takeaway, and 2) shows you’re an industry expert.
Use your c...
2 years ago
-
Foot Locker Crushed Q2 Earnings Expectations Sending Stock Higher
-
Plus, AstraZeneca said its antibody therapy reduced the risk of developing
COVID-19 symptoms by 77%, The Topps Co’s SPAC merger is off, and Elon Musk
annou...
2 years ago
-
Elliott Wave Stock Market Update - July 10th
-
The market has continued its rally to higher highs and it doesn't seem like
it wants to stop. We now have a new ATH at 4371 which are NASDAQ levels
s...
2 years ago
-
The Psychology of QE is Far More Important Than the Amount of It
-
Let's discuss what QE really does vs the psychology of QE.
2 years ago
-
Hello world!
-
Welcome to WordPress. This is your first post. Edit or delete it, then
start writing!
3 years ago
-
Trading: Opportunities Are Dispersed
-
Opportunities are dispersed. You might have an... *READ THE REST OF THE
ARTICLE ON THE NEW WEBSITE: JIM ROGERS TALKS MARKETS *
*Jim Rogers is a legendary i...
3 years ago
-
Market Signals for the US stock market S and P 500 Index and Indian Stock
Market Nifty Index for the Week beginning November 09
-
Indicator Weekly Level / Change Implication for S & P 500 Implication for
Nifty* S & P 500 3509, 7.32% Bullish Bullish Nifty 12264, 5.34% Neutral **
Bullis...
3 years ago
-
-
Fully Automated Trend Trading w/ Stocks Or Options
-
There’s a lot of research to support the usage of trend indicators as
simple risk reduction elements that can be layered onto an existing
strategy. Howev...
3 years ago
-
2020 Top Investment Picks – Q3 Update
-
At the beginning of the year, I put together a list of Top Investment Picks
for 2020 from the investment community and track them on this website. This
is ...
3 years ago
-
Upside-Down Markets: Profits, Inflation and Equity Valuation in Fiscal
Policy Regimes
-
I just published a new long-form piece through OSAM entitled “Upside-Down
Markets: Profits, Inflation and Equity Valuation in Fiscal Policy Regimes.”
In th...
3 years ago
-
The last of 12326
-
February 22nd 2012.....
First post...
https://permabeardoomster.blogspot.com/2012/02/can-anyone-fly-plane.html
--
This post will be the last under the o...
3 years ago
-
-
6/7 to 10/7, 2020 Nifty & Bank Nifty, Bharat Forge, IBhasgFin & RIL.
Weekly futures Pr...
3 years ago
-
Ultramarathoner Runs Over 200 Miles in Backyard, Wins Golden Toilet Paper
Roll
-
Strange times indeed. In the land “BC,” before coronavirus, people ran long
distances in foot races, and toilet paper wasn’t coveted. Things have
changed. ...
3 years ago
-
One Year Later
-
A year ago today I lost my father and my best friend, everyone here lost
their mentor and a friend. Dad and I spent the last 7 years of his life
living tog...
4 years ago
-
-
Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) Retreating Towards Key Support Around
$25.60-$27
-
AMD has failed to clear the
2018 high around $34.20. It is retreating, and has broken an
August/September sup...
4 years ago
-
Advanced Search is Now on Stocktwits
-
Advanced Search Is Now on Stocktwits
Come rain or shine, the Stocktwits community shares over 200,000 messages
per day. That includes charts, news, trade i...
4 years ago
-
Nightly Algo Report – December 6, 2018
-
To access this post, you must purchase Premium Plan or Premium Plan -
Annual.
The post Nightly Algo Report – December 6, 2018 appeared first on
Elliottwa...
5 years ago
-
Don’t be Fooled by the Pullback in the Dollar Because….
-
Don’t be fooled by the pullback in the U.S. dollar today because the
greenback could still strengthen further before the end of the year. Nearly
all of the...
5 years ago
-
A look at the bull market ahead
-
My latest missive on the near-term stock market outlook can be seen at
Financial Sense web site. You can see it by clicking on the following link:
https:/...
6 years ago
-
Weekly Videos
-
This week’s video will be posted on the new home for Short Takes. If all
goes well, it will appear sometime between 6:00 and 8:00 pm ET.
6 years ago
-
Gold Miners near a buy zone
-
Gold cleared a several month long consolidation a few weeks ago as it
cleared $1300, and has since been consolidating as it drifts back to […]
The post G...
6 years ago
-
Current Account Deficits and Safe Assets
-
The International Monetary Fund has issued its External Sector Report for
2017, and among its key findings: “Global current account imbalances were
broadly...
6 years ago
-
Kafka For The Twenty First Century
-
I've been spending a slightly frustrating day trying to update my payment
details at google. To log in to my admin console I need to log in using my
G Sui...
7 years ago
-
Gold Unleashed by Fed
-
Gold's next major upleg was likely unleashed by a very-dovish FOMC this
week, which now has its hands tied on hiking rates or being hawkish due to
the US e...
7 years ago
-
August 24th Blogger Sentiment Poll
-
There are more bulls than bears in this week's poll. Blogger Sentiment Poll
Participants: 24/7 Wall St (N) Carl Futia (+) Dash of Insight (+) Elliot
Wave L...
14 years ago
My Favorite Books
- The Intelligent Investor
- Liars Poker
- One up on Wall Street
- Beating the Street
- Remniscience of a stock operator
India Market Insight
-
Donald Trump cannot post bond covering $454 million civil fraud judgment
-
[image: Donald Trump cannot post bond covering $454 million civil fraud
judgment] With interest, Trump owes $456.8 million. In all, he and his
codefendants...
9 hours ago
-
Gann — Indicators and Signals for Nifty Stocks 18-22 March 2024
-
HOW TO TRADE GANN LEVELS Reliance Trend Deciding Level:2830 Weekly
Resistance:2857,2884,2911,2938 Weekly Support: 2802,2775,2748,2729 HDFC
BANK Trend...
22 hours ago
-
Rupee falls 29 paise to close at 82.68 against US dollar
-
During the day, the rupee touched a high of 82.45 and a low of 82.68
against the greenback. On Friday, the rupee had settled at 82.39 against
the dollar.
9 months ago
-
-
ES Hourly cloud and 4 Hour chart
-
- ES Hour moving towards the hourly cloud which may act as resistance.
- 4 Hour chart shows a possible bullish candle which may give new high's
...
2 years ago
-
JUST NIFTY BLOG 10-01-2020
-
Bulk Deals FII DII Stats Date # of Deals Total Volume (In Millions)
01-01-1970 0 0.00 Click here to see all Bulk Deals Date Category Buy Amount
(Rs. Cror...
4 years ago
-
Vist Note on Federal Bank
-
We recently met the senior management of Federal Bank which is one of the
old private sector banks with a distribution network of 1252 branches (48%
Kerala...
5 years ago
-
Nifty Bulls bounces ferociously holding 9930,EOD Analysis
-
FII's bought 4.8 K contract of Index Future worth 262 cores ,9.7 K Long
contract were added by FII's and 4.8 K Short contracts were added by FII's.
Net Ope...
6 years ago
-
Midcap & Smallcap Index Corrects, Lets Come Back To Fundamentals Again
-
Midcap Index had made a high of 18511 on 16th May 2017, fell almost 7% and
is currently trading at 17230. Smallcap Index made all time high of 7679 on
11th...
6 years ago
-
Market outlook for 30/10/2016
-
*Nifty closed up 22.75 points (0.26%) at 8638.00* while Future closed at
8667.40, premium of 29.40 points.
*Bank Nifty closed up 41.35 points (0.21%) at 19...
7 years ago
-
Option Open Interest for 28-10-2016
-
Inference The index opened flat to positive and after making an initial low
around 8581 saw some short covering to close at 8638.00, gain of 22.75
points. ...
7 years ago
-
Market Review for 23rd August 2016
-
*Nifty (8629)* we said ‘technically trend is still intact but there exists
selling pressure near 8746 and support around 8600 zones’ the Nifty
unfolded as...
7 years ago
-
ITC To Resume Cigarette Manufacturing
-
ITC manufactures a range of cigarette brands, including India Kings,
Classic, Gold Flake, Navy Cut, Capstan, Bristol, Flake, Silk Cut, which are
manufactur...
7 years ago
-
My Asset Allocation Strategy (Indian Market)
Cash - 40%
Bonds - 20%
Fixed deposit - 20%
Gold - 5%
Stocks - 10% ( Majority of this in dividend funds)
Other Asset Classes - 5%
My belief is that stocks are relatively overvalued compared to bonds and attractive buying opportunities can come along after 1-2 years. In a deflationary scenario no asset class does well other than U.S bonds, the U.S dollar and the Japanese yen, so better to be safe than sorry with high quality government bonds and fixed deposits. Cash is the king always. Of course this varies with the person's age.